If you're self-employed under CIS, the question is: what software handles deductions properly, works on your phone, and doesn't feel like accountant software?
From 6 April 2026, if your gross self-employed income is over £50,000, you'll need MTD software.
If you're under CIS, the key thing is not just “is it MTD compatible?” It’s does it actually handle CIS properly?
For most CIS subcontractors, FreeAgent is the best all-round option if you can get it free through NatWest or Mettle. QuickBooks is strong if you want better mobile receipt capture. Coconut is worth a look if you want something simpler and more built for sole traders.
If you want a genuinely free option, you have fewer choices. Some free tools work for MTD, but not all deal with CIS cleanly.
1. CIS support.
It needs to record contractor payments and CIS tax deducted correctly.
2. Works on your mobile.
If you're on the go all day, you need something that works properly on your phone.
3. MTD submissions.
It has to handle quarterly updates to HMRC.
4. Friendly pricing.
You probably don't need a £30–£50/month accounting system designed for bigger businesses.
These are the options actually worth looking at if you're self-employed under CIS and want something simple that works.
| Software | Monthly cost | CIS support | Mobile use | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FreeAgent | Free or £19/mo | ✓ | ✓ decent | Best all-round choice |
| QuickBooks Sole Trader | £10/mo + VAT | ✓ | ✓ best app | Best for phone-first use |
| Coconut | From £7/mo | ✓ | ✓ simple app | Best if you want something lighter |
| Xero | £16/mo + VAT | ✓ | ✓ | Best if your accountant uses it |
| Clear Books | Free | ✓ basic | ✗ | Best free option if cost matters most |
| My Tax Digital | Free | ✓ manual | ✗ | Best if you want to keep spreadsheets |
Free with NatWest / Mettle
or £19/month
If you want the clearest all-round answer, this is probably it.
FreeAgent handles CIS properly, keeps things simple, and doesn't feel like bloated business software. It also gives you a live view of what you've earned, what tax has already been deducted, and roughly where you stand.
The mobile app isn't the strongest part of FreeAgent, which is the main downside. But if your priority is getting CIS and MTD right without overcomplicating things, it's one of the safest choices.
Paid
best if you're mostly on your phone
If you're on site all day and hate paperwork, QuickBooks is probably the easiest one to live with day to day.
The app is better than FreeAgent's for snapping receipts and logging things quickly. It also supports CIS, which is the big thing.
The trade-off is that it feels a bit more like software software. Less calm, more dashboard. Still, if mobile use matters most, this is one of the strongest options.
From £7/month
simple sole trader option
Coconut is worth a look if you want something built more for sole traders than for accountants.
It supports CIS, works well on mobile, and feels lighter than Xero or QuickBooks. That's its main advantage. It doesn't feel like a bigger system than you need.
If FreeAgent feels a bit clunky on mobile and QuickBooks feels a bit too “full accounting platform”, Coconut sits in the middle.
Paid
best if your accountant wants it
Xero does handle CIS, and some subcontractors will end up on it because their accountant prefers it.
But for a sole trader who just wants something simple, it can feel like more than you need.
If you've already got an accountant who uses Xero, fair enough. If you're choosing from scratch and want the easiest setup for yourself, FreeAgent or Coconut will usually feel more natural.
Free
best if cost matters most
If your main goal is “I just need something that works and I don't want to pay much”, Clear Books is worth looking at.
It can handle the basics, including CIS in a more limited way, and it covers MTD. But it is not the slickest option, and it's not the best if you want to do everything from your phone.
Think of it as a practical budget option, not the nicest user experience.
Yes — but not on its own.
A spreadsheet can't send MTD updates to HMRC by itself. If you want to keep your spreadsheet, you need bridging software.
That can work. But for most CIS subcontractors, if you're changing system anyway, it's usually easier to move to proper MTD software rather than bolt another tool on top.
A lot of CIS subcontractors are asking the same thing: is it easier to just pay someone and forget about it?
For some people, yes.
If your records are messy, your income is mixed, or you just cannot be bothered, paying an accountant may still be worth it.
But if your real question is:
> do I need to pay £200/month just because of MTD?
The answer is usually no.
For many sole trader CIS setups, decent software plus one accountant review at year end is enough.
Pick FreeAgent if you want the safest all-round CIS + MTD option and can get it free.
Pick QuickBooks if you're mostly on your phone and want the best mobile app.
Pick Coconut if you want something simpler and more built for sole traders.
Pick Xero if your accountant wants you on Xero.
Pick Clear Books if you want the cheapest route and can live with a rougher experience.